Labour Arbitration

Labour Arbitration

Introduction to arbitration 

Arbitration is the most common method of resolving disputes in unionized workplaces, and is called for in collective agreements – the negotiated contract between employees (represented by their union) and employers.  

Arbitration vs mediation

Prior to an arbitration process, parties may attempt to resolve their issues via an informal workplace mediation process. Read about the differences between mediation and arbitration.

Arbitration clauses

These agreements almost always contain sections that call for a third party decision maker (arbitrator) to decide the outcome of unresolved disputes between the parties, so that every little disagreement does not end in a strike or a lock-out.  Where such a provision is not in a collective agreement, the law in most, if not all, jurisdictions in Canada mandates that a section requiring arbitration be deemed to be included in the agreement.  For example, in Ontario, if an agreement does not contain such a provision, the law requires that following clause be deemed to be a part of it:

“Where a difference arises between the parties relating to the interpretation, application or administration of this agreement, including any question as to whether a matter is arbitrable, or where an allegation is made that this agreement has been violated, either of the parties may after exhausting any grievance procedure established by this agreement, notify the other party in writing of its desire to submit the difference or allegation to arbitration…”
 (Labour Relations Act, 1995, SO 1995, c 1, Sch A, s.48(2))

Grievances leading to arbitration

Where an individual employee or the union as a whole believes that the employer has violated the collective agreement, a “grievance” may be filed by the union.  The grievance will state what has been done wrong, and what the complainant believes the remedy should be if the grievance succeeds.  

Arbitration process

Where the dispute is not resolved once the employer has considered the grievance, and depending on the specific process laid out in the collective agreement, the issue will go before an arbitrator to resolve.  The arbitration process is similar to court, with one or more adjudicators hearing the case and determining the outcome.  The union and employer may have lawyers representing them.  The arbitrator(s) may be agreed upon by the parties, or may be appointed by the Minister for labour in that jurisdiction.  Evidence will be provided to the arbitrator(s) to consider, and witnesses will often be called.  

Arbitration proceedings

However, the proceedings are much more informal than in court.  An arbitration will often be held in a boardroom or office, and normal court rules are generally more lax.  An arbitrator will most often release his or her decision must faster than a court would.  Furthermore, given that the parties will likely have had a long history of bargaining together or of prior arbitrations, they may agree to certain aspects of the case without conflict so as to speed up the process, and ask the arbitrator to merely focus on one or more of the most contentious issues.

Binding decision

The decision of the arbitrator will be binding.  While the losing party may appeal the decision in court (called “judicial review”), labour arbitrators are given much leeway for their specialized knowledge in the field, and often the outcome of the arbitration will only be overturned if it is outside the scope of what could be considered a reasonable decision.

Conclusion about labour arbitration

Arbitrations in labour law are extremely common, and this method of dispute resolution has taken immense pressure off of the court system.  Most issues can be solved efficiently and cheaply in this way. If you are in need of a workplace conflict coach, mediator or arbitrator, search the Mediate2go mediation services directory.

About the blogger: workplace arbitration

Johanna Willows, Labour Law Blogger

Johanna Willows is a lawyer in Winnipeg, representing unions and individual employees. Johanna received her law degree from the University of Ottawa in 2013. She received several awards upon graduation for her work and extracurriculars in labour, employment, and human rights law, and was recently awarded the Manitoba Bar Association Pro Bono award. See the rest of her bio on the Mediate to Go About page.

Mediate to Go: Labour Arbitration

Recruiting Mediators - Zoekt bemiddelaars

Mediate2go.com: Best Mediation Directory, Recruiting Mediators in Your Area

 

We are looking for mediators, conflict coaches, facilitators and arbitrators in your area. 

We are not just any mediation directory, we have a solid social media marketing strategy to promote your practice. All you need to do is post your profile, and we will market your business. Mediate2go is perfect for mediators who are on the go, but don't want to compromise professional practice, while still saving on costs of marketing. 

Here is how we help:

1. Social Media Savvy: We are your social media strategy. Just put up your directory listing, and we promote your services all over social media sites and search engines.
2. Mobile App Technology: Our web app is perfectly designed to work on any mobile device, so your listing is easily searchable on any phone, tablet or desktop computer.
3. Search Engine Boost: Search engine search-ability is your key to a successful business. Just register, and we do the rest.
4. Boost Search Engine Rating: Even if you already have a website, putting your profile on the Mediate2go directory will help improve your search engine rating.
5. Immediate Credibility: By signing up with Mediate2go you show potential clients that you are a credible mediator. When we market our service, you get the benefits.
6. International Reputation: We actively market our services to the world, so your directory will get international presence.
7. Easy to use: Set up your profile within 5 minutes, it's that easy! 
8. Client Targeted Marketing: We have a smart online marketing strategy, so we focus on attracting potentially paying customers.
9. Save Time: With the Mediate2go case manager, you not only get a directory listing, but a case management system that allows clients to request cases themselves, saving you time on the phone.
10. Added Value: We are not just a directory, we also help you save time on case intake, and go looking for potential clients. 

Mediate2go.com: Best Mediation Directory, Recruiting Mediators in Your Area

In Nederlands: Bemiddelingskantoor zoekt bemiddelaars in uw omgeving

Bemiddelingskantoor zoekt bemiddelaars in uw omgeving. We zoeken bemiddelaars, conflict coaches, facilitators en arbiters.

We zijn niet zomaar een bemiddelingskantoor, we bezitten een rotsvaste social media strategie om ons bedrijf te vertegenwoordigen. Alles wat je hoeft te doen is een profiel aanmaken, en wij vermarkten uw bedrijf. Mediate2go is perfect voor bemiddelaars die veel op weg zijn maar zich op professioneel gebied niet willen beperken en tegelijkertijd hoge kosten van de marketing willen besparen.

Hoe wij u kunnen helpen:

1. Social Media: met onze social media strategie zullen alle services van uw bedrijf vertegenwoordigd worden via social media en zoekmachines. 
2. Mobiele App Technologie: onze app is perfect ontworpen voor elk type telefoon, tablet of computer.
3. Zoekmachine: een goede bereikbaar- en vindbaarheid via zoekmachines is het visitekaartje van een succesvol bedrijf. Registreer het bedrijf en wij doen de rest. 
4. De zoekmachine ratings: naast je eigen website vergroot een profiel op Mediate2go de vindbaarheid en aantallen via een zoekmachine aanzienlijk.
5. Betrouwbaarheid: door je in te schrijven bij Mediate2go, laat je potentiële klanten zien dat je een betrouwbare bemiddelaar bent. Wanneer wij onze service vermarkten, heeft u daar alle voordelen van. 
6. Internationale bekendheid: ons bedrijf wordt wereldwijd actief vertegenwoordigd, dit zorgt voor internationale aanwezigheid en mogelijkheden voor uw bedrijf. 
7. Simpel in gebruik: stel uw profiel op in slechts 5 minuten!
8. Klantgerichte marketing: we hebben een slimme online marketingstrategie, waarbij er direct gericht wordt op potentiële klanten. 
9. Bespaar tijd: met de Mediate2go casemanager, krijg je een managementsysteem waarbij je klanten efficiënt geregistreerd worden en klanten direct zaken kunnen opvragen zodat er tijd wordt bespaard.
10. Bespaar 75%: Mediate2go biedt de meest betaalbare mogelijkheden waardoor er geld bespaard wordt wat u op andere manieren kunt investeren. 
11. Bijkomende voordelen: behalve de marketing, kunnen wij uw veel tijd besparen op zowel intakes als het aantrekken van nieuwe klanten.

Search #Best-Mediation-Directory, #Search-Mediator, #I-need-a-mediator